Many saints have experienced raptures, or ecstasies. Is this something that should be expected by lay persons today? Or sought after? Why do you think that ecstasies are a part of God’s design for faith experiences? How do experiences of ecstasy and rapture compare with St. Paul’s encouragement to “earnestly desire the higher gifts”? (See 1 Cor. 12:27) In that passage, the higher gifts are contrasted with the work of apostles, prophets, teachers, workers of miracles, and so on. Our nature is a

May 24, 1:48 PM

VisitationSiste: Our nature is a body-soul union. However, St. Francis states that the ecstasy of sensual pleasure degrades us, while ecstasy of pleasure in God raises us up. Why is this?

May 24, 1:48 PM

VisitationSiste: Back to the Treatise on the Love of God Sun chat May 27 730pm est

May 27, 4:45 PM

Guest4283 (Guest): Hi Sister Susan ! Going to Kairos this evening , please keep the Men in your prayers and the ladies who recently finished retreat ! God Love You All ! Have a Wonderful Chat ! Brian

May 27, 7:36 PM

Dawn (Guest): Hi Carol Ann and Ruth! God be with us

May 27, 7:38 PM

Ruth (Guest): And with you, too, Dawn. Thank you for your witness of God’s loving mercy – how he led you back to himself and gave you important work to do in your local parish.

May 27, 7:38 PM

Carol Ann: Hi Dawn, Hi Ruth

May 27, 7:39 PM

Dawn (Guest): Thank you for hearing and listening

May 27, 7:39 PM

Ruth (Guest): Hi Carol Ann. How are you?

May 27, 7:40 PM

Ruth (Guest): I wonder if Sr. Susan will be coming back to the chat.

May 27, 7:40 PM

Dawn (Guest): I was just wondering the same

May 27, 7:40 PM

Ruth (Guest): BRB have to get a jacket.

May 27, 7:41 PM

Dawn (Guest): ok

May 27, 7:41 PM

Carol Ann: I am not sure, because of the holiday. it sure looks like Sr. Susan planned to be here

May 27, 7:42 PM

Dawn (Guest): maybe something urgent came up?

May 27, 7:42 PM

Carol Ann: May be. We are mis s ING lots of people tonight

May 27, 7:45 PM

Ruth (Guest): Let’s try – back to St. Francis de Sales TREATISE ON THE LOVE OF GOD.

May 27, 7:45 PM

Dawn (Guest): Not that I completely do, esp at first, but this lesson seemed easier or closer. I thought and was grateful for all the work Sr puts in for our chats. yes, less tonight but maybe they will come

May 27, 7:45 PM

Dawn (Guest): Im in agreement Ruth, we could just start?

May 27, 7:46 PM

Dawn (Guest): 1.Many saints have experienced raptures, or ecstasies. Is this something that should be expected by lay persons today? Or sought after?

May 27, 7:46 PM

Ruth (Guest): Good that the content is more limited, but I’m not sure I even know what an ecstacy is – although I am very familiar with a sculpture of St. Theresa of Avila in ecstacy.

May 27, 7:47 PM

Dawn (Guest): I too thought of her! I wonder if term is used in same way...Sr Susan would know

May 27, 7:48 PM

Ruth (Guest): I don’t think we should seek ecstacy but be open to it. And that generally means being focused on the Lord.

May 27, 7:48 PM

Carol Ann: I think ecstasy in prayer is when Jesus lifts you up to Himself and gives you a deeper experience

May 27, 7:49 PM

Dawn (Guest): So this can happen without our intention. It is a grace from God

May 27, 7:49 PM

Carol Ann: Teresa of Avil, John of the Cross, Julian of Norwich . Mary Magdalena dePazzi, so many

May 27, 7:49 PM

Ruth (Guest): I think Sr. T and St. John of the Cross use the term “unitive” as a higher state of mystical experience, in which, sometimes even the human faculties are suspended. I suspect it is the same thing.

May 27, 7:50 PM

Dawn (Guest): good point.

May 27, 7:50 PM

Ruth (Guest): It is an experience of being united with God.

May 27, 7:50 PM

Carol Ann: Yes, we cannot will it for ourselves or we run the chance of prayer of the imagination at beSt or simple self delusion at worst

May 27, 7:51 PM

Dawn (Guest): I did not understand when he mentioned the danger of confusing the two? maybe he didnt use that term

May 27, 7:51 PM

Dawn (Guest): Intellect and affections?

May 27, 7:51 PM

Ruth (Guest): I’ve had some powerful experiences in prayer, positive, but I don’t think any of was ecstasy.

May 27, 7:52 PM

Dawn (Guest): this makes it more clear, maybe that is the danger he spoke of when we try on our own to make it happen

May 27, 7:53 PM

Ruth (Guest): Yes, those are the human faculties that seem to be “put on hold” while God does his work in an individual. But you are right, Carol Ann, if we SEEK such experiences we do run the risk of self-delusion.

May 27, 7:54 PM

Carol Ann: I think the more time we spend in prayer the more often the experiences will be stronger since we have the ears of our souls tuned in

May 27, 7:54 PM

Ruth (Guest): I once had three individuals on one psychiatric ward who all were sure that they were God or Christ and that the other two were just impostors who THOUGHT that they were God!

May 27, 7:55 PM

Carol Ann: Oh dear. All at the same time?

May 27, 7:55 PM

Ruth (Guest): I like that expression, Carol Ann,the ears of our souls tuned in.

 

May 27, 7:56 PM

Ruth (Guest): Yes, Carol Ann. But their delusions started separately before they were admitted. It just became more complicated when they were all living together with more than a dozen other individuals.

May 27, 8:01 PM

Ruth (Guest): My bit about being a physician is, of course, tongue in cheek.

May 27, 8:01 PM

Dawn (Guest): yes

May 27, 8:02 PM

Ruth (Guest): Maybe not so far off topic, Dawn. There is a saying something like: God became Man so that Man could become God-like.

May 27, 8:03 PM

Carol Ann: And achieve union with God through the grace of God. Fill in the God shaped hole inside each one of us

May 27, 8:03 PM

Dawn (Guest): I believe we can experience something, or receive a grace from God and not be able to put it into words like a learned person would. but reconizing what you experienced was that which you just read

May 27, 8:04 PM

Ruth (Guest): What a difference, though, between the arrogant “gods in white coats, the poor deluded, psych patients, and the humble, loving persons who we call Saints who mirror for us some aspects of the True God, a little like Jesus mirrored for us the Father:He who sees me sees my Father.

May 27, 8:06 PM

Dawn (Guest): One is ego based, self based and the other would be selfless?

May 27, 8:07 PM

Carol Ann: That is a good description

May 27, 8:07 PM

Ruth (Guest): That is what is so special about our Catholic Faith, and all Christian Faiths: God is not ONLY “out there” utterly transcendent, but also within each person, immanent.

May 27, 8:08 PM

Dawn (Guest): when we can empty ourself of our self, then God can come in

May 27, 8:08 PM

Ruth (Guest): We can have a relationship with our God – even a covenant relationship; and he takes the initiative.

May 27, 8:09 PM

Dawn (Guest): it is the depth of Christianity, the fullness

May 27, 8:09 PM

Carol Ann: Through contemplation

May 27, 8:09 PM

Dawn (Guest): like....he places in us a desire for him

May 27, 8:10 PM

Ruth (Guest): We prepare ourselves by meditating – best with Sacred Scripture, through which he talks to us – and by attentively being PRESENT.

May 27, 8:11 PM

Carol Ann: We are born with it. And we will try to fill it with wrong things if no one teaches us how to pray

May 27, 8:11 PM

Ruth (Guest): Being in his Eucharistic PRESENCE, helps a great deal.

May 27, 8:11 PM

Dawn (Guest): Do your parishes have adoration?

May 27, 8:11 PM

Ruth (Guest): God shaped hole” Yes, it is what I call being born hungry and thirsty.

May 27, 8:12 PM

Dawn (Guest): so beautiful!

May 27, 8:13 PM

Dawn (Guest): Question 2, in part is being answered here. but Sr asks us whay do we think ecasties are part of Gods design for faith

May 27, 8:13 PM

Dawn (Guest): why not whay

May 27, 8:15 PM

Carol Ann: Yes, there is usually an hour in one evening a week. Other parishes I visit, others not even that. I went to a mission to pray the other day between appointments and could not go in the church because of tours. The lady did not offer a chapel where Jesus is in repose

May 27, 8:15 PM

Dawn (Guest): I feel sad about it

May 27, 8:16 PM

Ruth (Guest): Dawn, here it is only about three hours per week that the Blessed Sacrament is exposed in a monstrance. But he is there to be adored in the tabernacle all the time. Trouble is, often the churches are closed, locked, and even those that remain open during the daytime are not on a predictable schedule. So you can drive 14 miles or more to stand before locked doors. Still I’ve sometime just sat in my car in bad weather or walked around outside the church in good weather just to be a little nearer to the Bo

May 27, 8:16 PM

Carol Ann: I think ecstasis are given when Jesus knows we need them to sustain our faith

May 27, 8:16 PM

Ruth (Guest): Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity hidden in a piece of bread I do not even see.

May 27, 8:17 PM

Ruth (Guest): That makes sense, Carol Ann – or at least some sort of mystical experience of his loving presence.

May 27, 8:17 PM

Dawn (Guest): This parish here does not have adoration, neither are the doors open until Mass. Another parish 35 miles has Adoration the first Friday of each month, all day

May 27, 8:18 PM

Ruth (Guest): That’s hard.

May 27, 8:18 PM

Dawn (Guest): I believe that is true Carol Ann. why we can truly say he is always with us and never abandons us

May 27, 8:20 PM

Ruth (Guest): On Saturday June 2, there will be Adoration all day in the attic of the Lodge “The Guggenheim” donated to the diocese by that family. The Adoration is specifically to help the women attending Rachel’s Vineyard retreat downstairs.

May 27, 8:20 PM

Carol Ann: We lock Jesus away from people who are looking for Him and then wonder why so few come on Sundays

May 27, 8:20 PM

Dawn (Guest): I read of a parish back east someplace. It was dead they said, no people hardly. the new priest began offering Latin Mass and it is now over flowing!! I saw pictures. and the doors are open regularly everyday posted hours. this gives me hope for the church!

May 27, 8:21 PM

Dawn (Guest): That is wonderful Ruth!

May 27, 8:21 PM

Carol Ann: Hmmm, same with religious life. More traditional orders are attracting so many these days. People are looking for stability

May 27, 8:22 PM

Dawn (Guest): Carol Ann a truth you speak!! this is the problem

May 27, 8:22 PM

Ruth (Guest): The monstrance at the Rachel’s Vineyard retreat is a carved wooden Madonna holding the host in her arms as she would the Child Jesus.

May 27, 8:22 PM

Carol Ann: How beautiful !

May 27, 8:23 PM

Dawn (Guest): Are you able to attend there Ruth?

May 27, 8:23 PM

Dawn (Guest): sounds so beautiful

May 27, 8:24 PM

Ruth (Guest): It truly is moving. And the retreatants go for adoration after the volunteers from outside (we enter by a back way to protect the anonymity of the retreatants). Yes, I am signed up for the 7 PM hour.

May 27, 8:25 PM

Dawn (Guest): I am happy for you

May 27, 8:25 PM

Carol Ann: That is so wonderful

May 27, 8:26 PM

Ruth (Guest): I am by nature/life experience inclined to be a little claustrophobic (there are no windows and the air is a bit stale) but I’ve never felt claustrophobic there, except maybe for a second – more like I am embraced.

May 27, 8:28 PM

Dawn (Guest): we were saying we could error in seeking this union, but St Paul says 1 Corin 12:27 we are to earnestly desire the higher gifts. perhaps the key word here is desire, we pray for, our soul longs for closer union. and we wait

May 27, 8:28 PM

Ruth (Guest): The following weekend I expect to participate in a CLM retreat – Commissioned Lay Ministers’ retreat at the diocesan retreat house that used to be a seminary.

May 27, 8:29 PM

Ruth (Guest): Good observation, Dawn.

May 27, 8:29 PM

Carol Ann: We are to desire them, but not try to make them happen.

May 27, 8:30 PM

Ruth (Guest): Exactly, Carol Ann.

May 27, 8:30 PM

Dawn (Guest): Ruth, the embrace you feel, would you say this is..I think the 2nd Sacred affection he speaks of ( StFDeSales) touched with love!

May 27, 8:31 PM

Ruth (Guest): Dawn, I’m not sure.

May 27, 8:33 PM

Dawn (Guest): StFDeSales writes so beautifully! it is like a poem almost

May 27, 8:34 PM

Ruth (Guest): I was just starting to write, that one of the most startling, wonderful, growth evoking experiences I’ve had was just before my 40th birthday. I had been, in the City of Munich, Germany, during my medical studies, carving out an hour per day for Eucharistic Adoration – various chapels. I had the schedule memorized, and traveled all over the city, mostly by bicycle, daily to find a chapel that was open.

May 27, 8:35 PM

Dawn (Guest): did you find a chapel?

May 27, 8:37 PM

Ruth (Guest): But it was while bicycling home from a hospital rotation, while crossing a long, narrow cemetary, that suddenly “out of the blue” I “heard” not with my ears, but clear as can be – innerly –Steig ab; ich moechte mit Dir sprechen. (Dismount – get off your bicycle. I want to talk with you!

May 27, 8:38 PM

Carol Ann: Ooh my!

May 27, 8:38 PM

Dawn (Guest): ohmygoodness!

May 27, 8:38 PM

Ruth (Guest): I’d found a chapel every day, often in a hospital; but God chose this bit of sacred ground to talk with me!

May 27, 8:39 PM

Ruth (Guest): Is that YOU Lord? I asked while obeying.

May 27, 8:42 PM

Carol Ann: What happened next?

May 27, 8:42 PM

Ruth (Guest): It was raining out, and I had on yellow nylon rain cape. The cemetery was only a few hundred feet across, but at least a kilometer long. Normally I just crossed it, but this time he led me to push my bicycle the length of it, although I did not even know if there was an outlet at the end.

May 27, 8:43 PM

Ruth (Guest): He went on:Forty years I’ve been walking with you.

May 27, 8:43 PM

Ruth (Guest): I’d

May 27, 8:47 PM

Ruth (Guest): known” the Lord, and belonged to him – knew (joyfully) that the rest of my life would have to be given to him, that is made a private consecration, from age 15 at the end of a three year “experiment” in Faith.Where were you, when . . . .? I asked, referring to some very hard, very early experiences. I could account for him walking with me for the past 25 years but not before that.

May 27, 8:48 PM

Ruth (Guest): He responded “Ich war da.

May 27, 8:48 PM

Ruth (Guest): (I was there.)

May 27, 8:48 PM

Dawn (Guest): Araimac?

May 27, 8:49 PM

Dawn (Guest): spelling!

May 27, 8:49 PM

Ruth (Guest): Over and over again we went through stations of my life, and he said,Ich war da.

May 27, 8:49 PM

Carol Ann: Ooo ooh

May 27, 8:51 PM

Ruth (Guest): No Dawn, German. He spoke to me in German – probably because everything else was in German during my work/study day and when I studied Scripture I always did it in both languages, so that I wouldn’t have to struggle with translating if I were, for example, in a prayer group.

May 27, 8:52 PM

Dawn (Guest): a mystical powerful experience.....

May 27, 8:53 PM

Dawn (Guest): I don’t mean to name it....just beautiful and sacred

May 27, 8:53 PM

Carol Ann: How did you feel when He spoke ?

May 27, 8:57 PM

Ruth (Guest): All the flowers seemed to become more beautiful, the air fresher. It was a Polish Cemetery; I didn’t pay attention to any of the stones or anything, only to His instruction.I was there. The voice was gentle, strong, reassuring. He corrected me. I had thought that he’d revealed himself to me when my “experiment” ended as an outcome of the three year “experiment” which I’d worked hard at and suffered a great deal in order to persist – while attending a public school, and with no one to talk with a

May 27, 8:57 PM

Ruth (Guest): about my search for THE TRUTH.

May 27, 8:59 PM

Dawn (Guest): so merciful is our God

May 27, 8:59 PM

Ruth (Guest): But he made it clear to me that I could not have even sought him had he not given me the hunger and thirst for Truth (the God-shaped hole, I guess you would call it Carol Ann).

May 27, 9:00 PM

Carol Ann: Yes, and He reminded you He is there even when you cannot see Him. We have that conversation a lot

May 27, 9:00 PM

Dawn (Guest): I think of the Samaritan woman at the well

May 27, 9:01 PM

Ruth (Guest): Toward the far end of the cemetery, after filling me with so much love and insight – and assurance that even when horrible things had happened to me as a child –

May 27, 9:01 PM

Dawn (Guest): her thrist and hunger, how she tried to fill it herself . he sees our hunger and thrist!

May 27, 9:02 PM

Dawn (Guest): please continue Ruth...

May 27, 9:02 PM

Carol Ann: Especially then is He there Ruth

May 27, 9:03 PM

Dawn (Guest): in our pain

May 27, 9:08 PM

Dawn (Guest): are you ok Ruth?

May 27, 9:08 PM

Dawn (Guest): prayers right now

May 27, 9:09 PM

Ruth (Guest): He was there. I’d protested a few times;I’m not even a parent, but I would not allow that to happen to ANY child! But his gentle reassurance:I was there, convinced me. He must have felt the cold kitchen floor on my left side after my mother had shaken me so hard that I could not respond at all(much later she told me she thought she had killed me.) And when I was nearly drowned in New Bedford bay and my brother pulled me out and my father resuscitated me.

May 27, 9:09 PM

Ruth (Guest): I’m Ok. Hard memories. But he was there. I am alive. More lives than a cat!

May 27, 9:09 PM

Carol Ann: I am praying too

May 27, 9:10 PM

Carol Ann: Lol,we have as many as He gives us

May 27, 9:10 PM

Ruth (Guest): Thank you. Yes. And we have or had the parents He gives us, too. So it is all good!

May 27, 9:10 PM

Dawn (Guest): He is here

May 27, 9:11 PM

Ruth (Guest): Indeed.

May 27, 9:11 PM

Ruth (Guest): Toward the end of this long, very reassuring experience, it seemed to me he asked me:Will you give me your children?

May 27, 9:15 PM

Dawn (Guest): this would be all those who came under your care?

May 27, 9:15 PM

Carol Ann: Your spiritual children ?

May 27, 9:18 PM

Ruth (Guest): I did not have any children. Perhaps I imagined that I might one day get married and have children. We chatted a little about that. But quickly I just told him, I wanted to do whatever it was He wanted me to do. All that I am all that I have, belongs to him. So if I was have children I would know that they belong to Him first and foremost. If he wanted me to become a nun, just make it clear, and I’d be there. If I were to stay single “in the world” that’s OK; the work of a doctor can be life-giving,

May 27, 9:20 PM

Dawn (Guest): Amen

May 27, 9:20 PM

Carol Ann: Wow,

May 27, 9:21 PM

Ruth (Guest): too. I think I had to go all the way back to the gate that I normally went out of. I have only a foggy memory of all that followed. But I was planted and watered in his care and I knew it, really, maybe for the first time.

May 27, 9:21 PM

Ruth (Guest): I felt at peace, maybe more so than ever before.

May 27, 9:23 PM

Carol Ann: That is so marvelous

May 27, 9:25 PM

Ruth (Guest): On my birthday I made macaroni and cheese, substituting practically all the ingredients. The mother of my goddaughter brought a salad. There were only four of us in my student apartment. It was a pleasant, very special birthday. I knew even more deeply than ever before,Mir gehoeren einander. (Bavarian dialect, something that an old married couple might say to one another:We belong to one another.

May 27, 9:27 PM

Ruth (Guest): Wow! I’ve/we’ve gone way overtime. Miriam called. I said I’d call her back. Please pray for her, for us. She went all through Catholic schools, and while I was in Europe she converted to Orthodox Judaism.

May 27, 9:27 PM

Ruth (Guest): She is very active in her synagogue.

May 27, 9:28 PM

Carol Ann: We could not stop so marvelous a story in the middle !

May 27, 9:29 PM

Ruth (Guest): Good night, dear friends in Christ. God bless your week,til we meet again.

May 27, 9:29 PM

Dawn (Guest): such a gift tonight. I thank Jesus our Lord for all tonight. I will pray for her and you and you Carol Ann, Sr Susan, all our chat sisters and brothers. Praise be to Jesus Christ for this most beautiful evening!

May 27, 9:29 PM

Carol Ann: Good night! God bless us every one, and those who could not be here

May 27, 9:30 PM

Dawn (Guest): Good night dear friends! God Bless us