Saint Francis now tells us that contempt for the counsels is a grave sin. Let’s talk about the fine line of distinction between what he has been saying about it being not a sin to not follow the counsels, but today we read that it is a sin to show contempt. What does he mean? Saint Francis mentions that it is a heresy for one to consider the married life as higher than chastity. What is he trying to say? Is he treating marriage as something second-class? For those of us who are not called to make

vows or promises according to the evangelical counsels, how can we nevertheless live in the spiritual of the evangelical counsels? For instance, how can a married couple practice chastity, how can a wealthy person practice poverty, and how can lay people practice obedience?
With that in mind, what can you say to the person who says,I am a good person. I am not guilty of really bad things. Why should I strive for perfection?

Sep 30, 7:24 PM

Judy (Guest): Hi Everyone! Well here we are at the beginning of Fall. Hard to believe, isn’t it! Before we blink, it will be Christmas. Oh my! So much to do. So much to think about!!

Sep 30, 7:39 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): well, to start- contempt in general I think would be a sin, contempt for anything

Sep 30, 7:39 PM

Ruth (Guest): Hi Sister. Hi Judy. Thank you, Sister, for doing such a good job of “cleaning up” last weeks chat. The guy who was trying to be disruptive discovered that he had a formidable “opponent. We all prayed for him.

Sep 30, 7:40 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Hi Sister Susan , Ruth , And Judy ! God Bless You ! Brian

Sep 30, 7:40 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): Hi Brian!

Sep 30, 7:40 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Hope you had a wonderful trip Sister!

Sep 30, 7:41 PM

Ruth (Guest): Brian, if you highlight the Guest and # and then type your name it replaces the #. No problem when there is only one Guest # but when there are several it gets a bit confusing.

Sep 30, 7:41 PM

Dawn (Guest): Hi Sr Susan Ruth Judy Brian!

Sep 30, 7:41 PM

Judy (Guest): Father Steve learned much about himself, was helped by many people younger than he, and was able to help others himself. As I said, it was a long journey, beginning on July 29, 2012 and a distance of 600 km. The title of the book is “A Priest’s Pilgrimage: Walking the Camino of Santiago de Compostela by Fr. Steve Ryan, SDB. It’s a worthwhile read.

Sep 30, 7:45 PM
Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): St Francis de Sales was a man of his time and a bit ahead of his time, but when it comes to religious life and the counsels he would expect Christians to respect them regardless of one’s own call

Sep 30, 7:45 PM

Judy (Guest): Well, lets hit question 1: While it is not a sin to not follow the counsels, to do so with contempt for the counsels could be. To hold in contempt something given by God is tantamount to contempt for God, for He would never give something that is worthy of contempt.

Sep 30, 7:47 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): Contempt is equivalent in some way to hate, would you say?

Sep 30, 7:47 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Anger

Sep 30, 7:48 PM

Dawn (Guest): This may have been discussed before, but Mother could you give some simple examples of counsels

Sep 30, 7:48 PM

Judy (Guest): Yes, I believe so. And certainly the counsels are not worthy of hate. Rather they should have our respect and admiration.

Sep 30, 7:49 PM

Dawn (Guest): I would say yes, contempt and hate are like the same

Sep 30, 7:49 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): poverty, chastity, obedience is what I think he is referring to

Sep 30, 7:49 PM

Ruth (Guest): This is a situation in which I think it is best to respect and honor those who are “called” to all the counsels but realize that even though EVERYONE or every baptized person is called to be a saint – that is to pursue perfection in whatever state in life he is in – not all are called to do so the way we traditionally thing of as following all the counsels.

Sep 30, 7:50 PM

Dawn (Guest): ok, yes. those are not commandments rather counsels. thank you

Sep 30, 7:50 PM

Ruth (Guest): I disagree about equating hate and anger.

Sep 30, 7:51 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): But we are all called to them in some measure as they are also virtues

Sep 30, 7:51 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): How would you explain it Ruth

Sep 30, 7:52 PM

Ruth (Guest): I am just beginning to recognize – probably because of so much literature about how bad anger is – that anger is simply an emotion. What you DO with it is what is important.

Sep 30, 7:53 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): where does contempt though fit in

Sep 30, 7:54 PM

Judy (Guest): Question 2: St. Francis considers is heresy to consider marriage as higher than chastity, because in chastity one lives solely for the Lord. In marriage, one lives for the spouse. However, while marriage is not higher than chastity, neither ia it lower because eadh is a gift given by the Lord for the well-being and growth of the individual. It should be remembered that marriage is a sacrament and living the counsels, even by vows, is not.

Sep 30, 7:55 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): I agree- welll written out Judy

Sep 30, 7:55 PM

Judy (Guest): I wonder if its sacramentality makes it a higher state than living the counsels.

Sep 30, 7:55 PM

Ruth (Guest): In fact, I now believe that to be angry about the right things is far better than to ignore them or “take” everything sort of in a laid back manner. Passions – any of them – CAN be dangerous, that is, lead to sin, but they are also the “STUFF” that makes saints. The opposite tends to be a sense of hopelessness, depression, or indifference.

Sep 30, 7:55 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): I wonder the same

Sep 30, 7:58 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): This is something that became an issue after Vatican 2

Sep 30, 7:58 PM

Judy (Guest): The state, in and of itself, is not higher, however one who embraces is can achieve a higher degree of holiness depending uon the sincerity and commitment with which s/he lives chastity. It is also possible for a married person to reach a higher degree of sanctity than one in chastity if he is more sincere and deeply committed than the other.

Sep 30, 7:59 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): The goal is holiness, yes, and the path is the one God’s Will chooses for you

Sep 30, 7:59 PM

Ruth (Guest): Good observation, Judy – initial statement. But I don’t think that the sacramentality of marriage makes it a “higher state” any more than the living of the counsels –as a “religious” makes that a higher state. (And I am glad that St. Francis recognized and stated what he did about comparing the two.

Sep 30, 8:01 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): I think comparisons are not helpful to people and may be harmful- better this, better that Best- find God’s will and follow it

Sep 30, 8:01 PM

Dawn (Guest): thank you

Sep 30, 8:01 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Amen Sister Susan !!!

Sep 30, 8:03 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): How can one live counsels as mentioned, in the single or married state- I see that as valid

Sep 30, 8:03 PM

Ruth (Guest): Another example of how a sacrament does not necessarily mark a “higher state”: Anointing of the sick. Is it “better” to be sick. A person MAY become holier by being sick, that is offering up suffering. But if the glory of God is a person FULLY ALIVE – good health can contribute to making the person better ABLE to live in charity. I think LOVE is the main measure, godly love: charity.

Sep 30, 8:03 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): Good point

Sep 30, 8:05 PM

Judy (Guest): Re: Question 3: A maried person can practice chastity by fidelity to the spouse, by caring for and not abusing the spouse and by living tghe laws of the Church concerning marriage. A wealthy person can practise poverty by being detached from possessions and being willing to give them to others who may be in need. Lay people practice obedience by observance of the Commandments of God and of the Church and yielding to all in lawful authority over them, as long as what is demanded is not sinful.

Sep 30, 8:05 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): We find God’s Will by really getting to know Him . It is easy to get away from knowing God by getting too religious ! Remember when Jesus said to the religious I Never Knew You Depart from Me !

Sep 30, 8:07 PM

Dawn (Guest): like Personal encounters with Christ

Sep 30, 8:07 PM

Ruth (Guest): There is a different sort of chastity for married couples than there is for single persons, but both are made holier by chastity. A celibate priest or single person “in the world” is called to one expression of chastity, a married person to another.

Sep 30, 8:07 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): This is a virtue that needs to be emphasized in the world today for sure

Sep 30, 8:08 PM

Ruth (Guest): Good summary, question 3, Judy.

Sep 30, 8:08 PM

Judy (Guest): Thanks, Ruth!

Sep 30, 8:10 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): It is beautful to strive for goodness as the counsels help us to do. How can we encourage people to want to be noble, pure in their state of life, and good.

Sep 30, 8:12 PM

Ruth (Guest): And think about it: All of the “religious” celibates, priests, member of various orders, communities, sisters, nuns, monks, etc. every one of them had parents! And most of those parents were married to one another. In fact, I’m not sure if it is still the church law, but the grown child of an illegitimate union used to be excluded from even being considered for one of those vowed states.

Sep 30, 8:12 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): By our example ! That’s what all the Saints have done for us !

Sep 30, 8:12 PM

Dawn (Guest): by our example of how we live, also to be a friend, to be a safe place for them to confide

Sep 30, 8:12 PM

Judy (Guest): Here goes question 4: Would we say o a person in a particular field of endeavor to stay in that same state always? We would more likely encourage the jperson to advance in that field so as to better himself and perhaps to contribute to the betterment of others as well. So to would we encourage others to strive for perfection rather than be satisfied with not doing bad things. In striving for perfection we give glory to God and honor to the Church.

Sep 30, 8:13 PM

Ruth (Guest): Yes, Dawn.

Sep 30, 8:13 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Listen Listen Love Love !!!

Sep 30, 8:13 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): Some people back off when they hear the word perfection

Sep 30, 8:13 PM

Ruth (Guest): So true, Brian.

Sep 30, 8:14 PM

Ruth (Guest): Perfectionism” is considered a fault.

Sep 30, 8:14 PM

Ruth (Guest): It sometimes gets in the way of the “good.

Sep 30, 8:14 PM

Ruth (Guest): And is often unattractive.

Sep 30, 8:15 PM

Dawn (Guest): so often as I read through our chats , humility, the virtue, seems to be the answer

Sep 30, 8:15 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Sometimes God’s Will is for us to live a simple life of service to others

Sep 30, 8:15 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): But actually we need to strive for it as it is similar to striving for heaven

Sep 30, 8:17 PM

Ruth (Guest): Perfection and perfectionism may not be the same, but the latter is somehow, it seems, equated with prissiness.

Sep 30, 8:17 PM

Dawn (Guest): As in, we need to train our self in humility

Sep 30, 8:18 PM

Dawn (Guest): to become, we need to train ourself . this would be striving for ?

Sep 30, 8:19 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): strivng but always asking for the grace of the action

Sep 30, 8:19 PM

Ruth (Guest): And even humility MUST be reality based, not just kicking oneself for not (yet?) being perfect.

Sep 30, 8:19 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Pride can easily take over in perfectionism we can miss opportunities to Love others or to simply be available to listen to others which is Soo powerful and healing

Sep 30, 8:20 PM

Judy (Guest): Jesus told us that unless we become as little children we cannot enter the kingdom of heaven. Children are simple, trusting, following those who are in authority. So we must be simple, trusting and following those who are in authority.

Sep 30, 8:20 PM

Ruth (Guest): Lord, give me the grace to use my two ears a lot more, and my mouth less!

Sep 30, 8:20 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Amen Judy !

Sep 30, 8:22 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): I Love You Guys Soo Much ! Thank You for all your Love Prayers and Support All these Year Together ! Praise God !!!

Sep 30, 8:22 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): Amen to that!

Sep 30, 8:22 PM

Dawn (Guest): Amen !

Sep 30, 8:23 PM

Ruth (Guest): Example to my point above: GK Chesterton, not yet canonized, but he may eventually be. Sts. was it Gertrude, and Hildegard – who became counselors to kings and heads of state.

Sep 30, 8:24 PM

Judy (Guest): Most of all, we must follow Jesus Who has taught us how to live a life that will lead us to heaven. He invites us to follow Him and although it is an invitation, we should be quick to obey it.

Sep 30, 8:25 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Amen Judy !!!

Sep 30, 8:26 PM

Ruth (Guest): True Judy, yet there are those who believe that they are following Jesus and have some sharply differing views on important matters: vis Pope Francis and

Sep 30, 8:26 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): Pray for all those who lose their way

Sep 30, 8:26 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): We can do all things through Christ who Strengthens Us !

Sep 30, 8:26 PM

Judy (Guest): Brian, you too are a blessing to us. You have such wisdom and have learned much from your ministry to prisoners. You share such wisdom with us and we are grateful.

Sep 30, 8:27 PM

Ruth (Guest): Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò

Sep 30, 8:28 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): a real chasm developing- stay close to the Lord to guide your heart

Sep 30, 8:28 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Judy you are a gifted writer who expresses God’s Love Soo beautifully through your written words ! A Great Inspiration to us all !!!

Sep 30, 8:28 PM

Ruth (Guest): Thank God that God himself, Jesus promised to be with his Church til the end of time! If it weren’t of HIS making, it would have collapsed long ago.

Sep 30, 8:29 PM

Judy (Guest): WWJD. Good letters to remember in times like these when there is so much “stuff” going on the world. What would Jesus do in our circumstances.

Sep 30, 8:29 PM

Dawn (Guest): words of wisdom Mother

Sep 30, 8:30 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): WE all have a gift of wisdom here as each is open to the Holy Spirit

Sep 30, 8:30 PM

Dawn (Guest): good to often reflect on this Judy, and if we ask him he will not abandon us and will let us know

Sep 30, 8:30 PM

Judy (Guest): And thank God for this Church which leads, guides and feeds us on our pilgrimage. Where would we be without the Church! We need the Church and the Church needs us.

Sep 30, 8:31 PM

Ruth (Guest): And let us reach out and open ourselves ever more to the inspiration of the Holy Spirit – who also gives the gift of discernment of spirits.

Sep 30, 8:31 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): Let the whirlwinds swirl, be centered in Jesus and all will be still within you

Sep 30, 8:31 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): Went to Student Mass tonight at University of Buffalo ! Awesome Group of Young College Students from around the World ! Leaders for our Lord Jesus in the making ! God is Good !!!!

Sep 30, 8:31 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): Praise God! Good news!

Sep 30, 8:31 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): This week is the synod on youth Keep it in prayer too

Sep 30, 8:32 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): Blessings to each of you!

Sep 30, 8:32 PM

Sister Susan Marie (Moderator): Good night!

Sep 30, 8:32 PM

Judy (Guest): May we all strive for perfection in the life to which God has called us! Have a blessed week, Good night!!!

Sep 30, 8:33 PM

Guest3198 (Guest): God Bless You All !!! Have a Great Week ! Keep Shining for Jesus ! Brian

Sep 30, 8:33 PM

Dawn (Guest): thank you all, thank you for this gathering and friendship, God Bless and be with us. goodnight

Sep 30, 8:33 PM

Ruth (Guest): Thank you Sister. But let us pray and fast during those whirlwinds, as Francis asks us to.

Sep 30, 8:43 PM

Ruth (Guest): Thank you, all of you, for your friendship and your prayers. Sister is right; I’ve been sort of “caught up in” the whirlwind – but hanging onto the Jesus of the Gospels for dear life! Today, after Mass, I asked the local pastor if today’s Gospel means that if reading the National Catholic Register or listening to the news disturbs me and, though it does not directly cause me to sin, at the very least it – and the memories provoked by these matters – distract me and make it harder for me to “get done”

Sep 30, 8:45 PM

Ruth (Guest): the things on my agenda, does this Gospel mean that I should avoid reading the NCR and avoid listening to the news (or watching it on my computer, since I do not have TV)?

Sep 30, 8:46 PM

Ruth (Guest): Gospel passage.

Sep 30, 8:49 PM

Ruth (Guest): Always, I’m “out of step, late, and too wordy. Sorry. Slow typing is a contributor to the problem. Good night all. Prayerful good wishes for a week filled with the blessings of knowing Jesus close at hand, the Holy Spirit inspiring, and pleasing the Father in all you do.